Calorie-Count About.com Health
This page looks way better on our new site!
Easier to use. More tools and features. 100% free.
Diet Forums : Pregnancy & Parenting (Library) Report Violation · Tag It!
Slings vs. Carriers for Newborns, Your thoughts/experiences please vanessa1031
  Jun 05 2008 19:52
I'm trying to decide whether to get a Sling or an actual front & Back carrier for times I want to bring the baby out for short walks without the stroller, or carry her around the house; but able to have my hands free.

Can anyone recommend a sling?  Or let me know your experience with a sling?  I like the look of them; but I want what is best for baby.  My height is 5"1 in case that matters; and after the baby is out I suspect I will be in 130-140 range of weight.  I'd like to go the sling route; but after doing homework on Consumer reports; and reading reviews; I'm not sure it is the safest route.

If you have had a good experience with a carrier that wasn't too bulky; please let me know which product you went with.

I appreciate everyone's response!
Page [1] 2 of 2 Post Reply
#21 swearimn Jul 04 2008 23:06
i bought the the maya wrap after reading this post, right before my vacation. it was amazing the best thing i ever bought.

it was a little difficult to adjust, but once you get the hang of it, it is a breeze. it was especially helpful in restaurants, i could breast feed and no one was the wiser.
#22 ainla Jul 08 2008 03:30

I used the MOBY wrap for the first few months. She loved it and was able to sleep in it for hours. Now that she's 4 months I'm switching to the bjorn. I really prefer the moby though. My friend just got a MAYA wrap and she's psyched.

#23 vanessa1031 Jul 09 2008 14:42
I FINALLY bought one-  it's a Dr. Sears wrap Balboa Baby Sling -  lots of factors to consider; and this one seemed reasonably priced plus it was adjustable.  They have another one size xs-s, s-m, and m-l:  and with the weight I plan to loose I really wanted an adjustable one. 

I'm not sure which will be delivered first....the sling or the baby!!!  1 more week and a few days to go!!

Thanks all for your advice.  It was a hard decision.
#24 niccimax Jul 09 2008 15:04
Original Post by swearimn:

i bought the the maya wrap after reading this post, right before my vacation. it was amazing the best thing i ever bought.

it was a little difficult to adjust, but once you get the hang of it, it is a breeze. it was especially helpful in restaurants, i could breast feed and no one was the wiser.

Amazing wrap for BF'ing in public!!!!  You can wear the baby in the sling while BF'ing and walk around a mall and nobody would know.  I LOVE this wrap.

My son is 3 and I still put him in it - if we are going for  a long walk and he gets tired he sits on my hip in the wrap and can snuggle in and keep warm... love it when he falls asleep on my shoulder.

#25 vanessa1031 Sep 03 2008 23:44
Hi ladies;

So; the sling is way too big I think for her.  she gets lost in it and i was afraid for her neck.  So; I'm going to use it when she gets a little older.  She just gets lost in there.  The instructions tell me to put some blankets in there for newborns; so; we'll see.

I also bought a front carrier -  so my DH could also use it-  I bought an Ergo-  and let me tell you it's amazing.  I put my little julia in it today and walked around the house.  Boom!  Naptime!  and she didn't cry at all when I put her in it.  Although I can honestly say she only cries when she's hungry.  (I really lucked out!)

The Ergo comes with a DVD that tells you how to put it on; which I love b/c I"m such a moron when it comes to reading instructions.  I had to put it on using a small pillow in instead of the baby so I could get used to it!  It only took me about 10 tries to really get the hang of it. 

I"m going to re-study my sling.  I still love them and just think I need to get the hang of them.  I won't give up!
#26 m0m6 Sep 04 2008 15:05

I tried to get a sling when my son was 2 months, but he hated it!! He was way too big for the stupid thing! He was almost 12 lbs at 2 months, though. He likes the front carrier now, but he is almost too big (again!) for the one I bought him. GRRR they grow so fast!

Page [1] 2 of 2 Post Reply
Welcome! Explore all our features with the Calorie-Count.com Walkthrough