| Diet Forums : Weight Loss (Library) | Report Violation · Tag It! |
| The 1200 calorie limit is the average over the week right? | ||
| May 11 2008 17:23 | ||
So yet another question abt the 1200 calorie limit :) Is this limit on a daily basis or can it be averaged over a week? I am asking this because on some days when I go out to eat or have a huge dinner, I go over my maintenace calories. The next day I end up eating a lot less, not intentionally but basically because I'm not hungry (and maybe a lilttle guilt as well!! ) If the average over the 2 days comes upto my maintenance calories of ~1400 is that Ok? |
||
| Page 1 of 1 | Post Reply | |
| #1 | May 11 2008 17:41 | |
|
Try to never eat less than 1200 calories on any day. The 1200 calories is meant to be the lower limit for women generally but it's really for women who are about 5 feet tall and 100 lbs. So it's likely that unless those are your stats you should be eating more anyway. So it's best not to go under 1200 if possible. It's easy to make up 100 or so cals at the end of the day, just eat a small handful of almonds for example or have a glass of milk or soymilk. If it happens once in a while it won't be bad though so don't stress about it too much. Also is your maintenance calorie target really only 1400? That is very very little so unless you are under 5 feet I doubt that you have an accurate number there, it should be significantly higher. |
||
| #2 | May 11 2008 18:27 | |
|
I'm 5'2 and my cal target ranges from 1295 - 1400. I think they are asking if, at the end of the week if you add up your weekly cals, then divide by seven, you should get about 1200. which is a nice way of keeping track of things remember that 1200 isn't a number to live and die by, go up and down from 1400-1200 and you will benefit a LOT. |
||
| #3 | May 12 2008 14:30 | |
Original Post by nycgirl: Actually, my calorie target range is 1200 calories and I'm 5'5. I weigh 145 and according to cc and my alli program these are the max number of calories I can consume if I want to reach my goal of 135 lbs. Of course, that's without exercising. If I throw in some exercise every few days I adjust my caloric intake accordingly. |
||
| #4 | May 12 2008 14:34 | |
|
valcatraz - I'm an inch taller than you, and when I was 145lb, I was eating 1500 and losing weight (I'm now at 135, and to get here, I was always aiming for 1500) - you don't have to eat 1200 to lose weight - eating more could make you lose a little slower (although exercise will bump up your burn rate), but at least my experience was that eating less than 1400 made my weightloss slow to a grinding halt. Just my experience - hope that helps. Good luck. |
||
| #5 | May 12 2008 14:35 | |
|
Average over the week, primarily, with this caveat:
Too many days in a row under your BMR (Basal Metabolic Rate) will cause your body to think it's starving, lower your metabolism, and store as much as it can. This is sometimes known as starvation mode. Be sure that your calorie target is high enough that you can average to it without eating below your BMR for too long.
To calculate your BMR, go here: http://www.bmi-calculator.net/bmr-calculator/ And previous posters here are absolutely correct; 1200 is the BMR for a VERY petite woman. It's considered an absolute minimum to get your required vitamins, minerals, protein, and fat (and yes, you do need some fats) for the day - and even then you can only do that with a lot of careful planning. Heck I eat 2000 calories a day and I sometimes have difficulty meeting my mineral intake goals. |
||
| #6 | May 12 2008 16:07 | |
|
Valcatraz, CC is wrong on this point. It does not take in account what your bmr is. It simply uses your activity level and subtracts a deficit with no regards to your BMR. I'm 5'4.5 and 133 lbs. My BMR (what I would burn in a coma) is 1400. When I first started CC I was 128lbs. I had input my weight and height and put my activity as sedentary (I like to manually add my exercise). However because i manually added my exercise the allowance tool was not accounting for it. It had me burning 1700 cals at sedentary (which is correct) and told me to eat 1200 cals/day to lose 1lb/wk. But.... my BMR is 1400. CC does not have a function that tells the BMR so it does not know where the deficit cut off should be. Too bad if 1700-500 = 1200. My BMR is 1400, that means the biggest deficit I can have at sedentary is 300. I ended up gaining 15lbs by eating 1200/day. I was not getting enough food to fuel my body so it started to store what i did eat. As soon as I raised my cals to 1500 I lost weight.
Trust me, 1200 cals is not enough for you!!!! calculate your BMR and do not go under it. |
||
| #7 | May 13 2008 02:43 | |
|
Oh i generally dont go under 1200- I am on maintenance mode- 5ft6", weighing 118 lbs and CC tells me that I need ~1500 calories a day to maintain. I was just asking if on some odd day I'm not hungry its ok to eat less than 1200 right..especially if i've eaten a 3000 calorie dessert the night before! The peanut butter/ nuts snacking just to come upto 1200 is not very appealing to me on the whole.. |
||
| #8 | May 13 2008 05:18 | |
Original Post by fat2fit77: Hmm, I want to check this for you as to the best of my knowledge CC target meters are only for weight loss, not maintenance or weight gain. I am 5'1" and lost 20 lbs (from 120 to 100 lbs) from May to September by eating 1500 cals a day so cannot imagine at 5'6" that is your maintenance. Let me look into it ........ |
||
| #9 | May 13 2008 12:02 | |
Original Post by nycgirl: thanks for checking up for me nycgirl. I got these numbers from CC by putting my lifestyle at sedentary and keeping my current weight and target weight the same- 118lbs. |
||
| #10 | May 13 2008 13:16 | |
|
fat2fit - nycgirl is right. I'm maintaining now, but if I use the calorie target tool, and say 135 starting, 135 goal, it tells me that if I eat 1400, I'll reach my target by... tomorrow. Use the burn meter tool to get your maintenance calorie target - what you burn is what you should eat. |
||
| #11 | May 13 2008 16:54 | |
|
okay ladies so maybe you could help me. I have started out on this site back in early April and thought that since I lost weight by severly restrciting my calories before that i shouldn't go over 800 or 900 a day. I am 5'2" currently weight 136 on a good day. I was told by posters to not go under 1200, but that i actually should eat about 1400 according to CC to get to my weight loss goal of 125lbs. I am a bit confused though because at first i thought maybe i am no burning enough in exercise and not eating enough when i do exercise, but feel so stuffed it if i consume 1400-1500 calories a day! The other day I was around 1400 calories and i had a good exercise regime 30-45 minutes, burning about 300-400 calories during that period. I try to exercise four times a week, but seem to get a little more in even on my rest days when i'm trying to relax because i have toddler twins and they keep my heart rate going on off days. BUt my questions are: Am I eating enough? ON off days what should my caloric intake be? on exercise days what should it be? And why am I not losing at 1400-1500 calories? I have been trying to stay at this rate for about two weeks now and i know that after you starve yourself your body is storing the food you finally eat, but I thought that my body would get used to the boost and finally start losing! I have been on here for a month and have lost what 1.2 lbs! UGH! What the freak?!?! HELP ME! |
||
| #12 | May 13 2008 18:01 | |
|
So I have confirmed it. You should not use the calculator to estimate the amount of calories you need to maintain. The way it is AT THIS MOMENT is that it is for Weight Loss only. However, I believe the Team is working on that so it might change soon. I agree, you need to use the burn meter (if it's set to sedentary you must plug all your stats into it). |
||
| Page 1 of 1 | Post Reply | |